Between hedging and balancing: Pakistan’s foreign policy choices

Pakistan's foreign policy choices

The strategic value of Pakistan’s foreign policy is made apparent by the growing geopolitical rivalry between the US and China, the war in Ukraine, the problems in the Middle East, and the US’s shift in focus from the Atlantic to Asia. In typical fashion, the international system is in chaos, which saddles the country with both obstacles and an opportunity to make these choices. In times gone by, Pakistan’s foreign policy was mainly spurred by security concerns; today, it is molded more by a combination of political, economic, and security strategies. At the regional level, Pakistan has to cope with an array of trouble spots on both its eastern and western edges, which are rendered more daunting by political unrest, internal instability, and ongoing security worries. How would Pakistan exploit and adjust to the changing reality?

Pakistan’s foreign policy, which is molded by structural hinges on external patterns and security concerns, fluctuates between realism and hedging. According to classical realism, states will resort to a strategy of survival, security, and balance of power to counter existential hazards, particularly ones emanating from India. In an effort to improve its visibility in the international system, Pakistan strives to pursue the strategies of survival, security, and power balance with India. To try to counteract its regional asymmetry against India, Pakistan often looks for potential alliances through structural realism in the unstable international system, especially in the Middle East and big countries like the US, India, China, and Russia.[1] Pakistan might opt for hedging instead of rigorous alignments, which can be expensive. An effective substitute is issue-based collaborations and strategic autonomy.

Global power politics and Pakistan’s apprehension

Pakistan has to carefully tackle the intensifying US-China rivalry on the international scene and avoid being forced to make a binary decision. Pakistan was an ally of the United States during the Cold War and the war on terror. Pakistan is more inclined to manage its relations with the United States due to its structural limitations, economic dependence on international financial institutions (such as the World Bank and IMF), and its receipt of foreign investment. From a hedging perspective, Pakistan should adjust to the cooperation relationships between the US and China rather than making a strict commitment that would turn it into a front-line state in their struggle.

The return of President Trump to the White House fuels another uncertainty rather than clarity, as Pakistan-US relations have remained fragile and transactional since the American withdrawal from Afghanistan. Pakistan loses its strategic value to Washington, which it is expected to resume. From a geopolitical perspective, Trump’s foreign policy is likely oriented toward deal-specific, personalized, and driven by economic mercantilism rather than alliance politics. The US National Security Strategy 2025 is a manifestation of this policy, which creates the openings for selective engagement, particularly in trade, cross-border terrorism, and investment in rare earth minerals.[2] Pakistan must therefore distance itself from a Cold War-type alignment towards a hedging strategy.

China, on the contrary, is an amiable partner in overcoming Pakistan’s strategic priorities; nonetheless, these ties ran into an array of difficulties. China is concerned about Pakistan’s internal security turmoil and the safety of its people who have been targeted by militants. Investor trust was undermined by an assortment of attacks on Chinese people, and persistent demands for payment rollover and financial assistance led to emotions of overburden and a mounting imbalance between China and Pakistan.

Pakistan is facing a two-frontal situation at the regional level.

Owing to New Delhi’s contentious moves in August 2019, Pakistan is facing a worsening regional situation that supports its grounded narrative of security and survival. Pakistan’s options have been hampered by India’s refusal to strategically isolate Pakistan and change Kashmir’s status. Pakistan may focus on crisis management and deterrence stability, but it does not currently anticipate breakthrough diplomacy.[3] Pakistan only has to contend with the alternatives of balancing military, averting escalation, and using diplomatic venues to keep the Kashmir problem intact with the international community.

Pakistan’s security predicament has been exacerbated by border conflicts with Afghanistan, its neighbor to the west. With the Taliban unwilling to move against militants’ hideouts in Afghanistan, Pakistan’s dreams of normalizing its Western frontier have been dashed by the rise of Taliban 2.0. The Durand Line’s status as an international border and cross-border terrorism, are Pakistan’s two main concerns with Afghanistan.[4] From a security dilemma perspective, Afghanistan is suspicious of Pakistan’s attempt to wipe out terror infrastructure as a way to strengthen its security. Pakistan is concerned about possible encirclement from both its eastern and western frontiers, which feeds worries and heightens fears of having to deal with a two-frontal crisis at its doorstep.

In this scenario, Pakistan has a number of difficulties in the shifting regional landscape while managing deterrence stability on the east and cannot afford kinetic steps on its western frontier. Therefore, Pakistan should consider trilateral and multilateral diplomacy, such as interacting with China, Qatar, or Turkey by recognizing regional security concerns and political engagements. Pakistan runs the risk of becoming embroiled in a low-level battle on both the East and West borders that depletes its political and economic resources if the cross-border militancy is not resolved.

Pakistan actively collaborates with Middle Eastern nations, including as Saudi Arabia, Iran, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, and other Gulf States, in accession to its near borders. Remittances, energy security, economic assistance, and diplomatic ties with Muslim Gulf States that share similar ideologies are the primary forces behind Islamabad’s agenda. However, Pakistan takes a bilateral and non-entanglement approach to Middle East disputes and carefully modifies its strategic ties with both Saudi Arabia and Iran, which are strategic adversaries.[5]

Way Forward

Because of its alliances with powerful nations like the US, China, and Russia, Pakistan has evolved into a liable regional nation with strategic value. The world is currently experiencing another era of wars that are upsetting the global order, following a period of peace. Pakistan is managing its options to maintain a balanced relationship with major nations including the United States, China, and Russia in this difficult global climate. Pakistan is attempting to steer clear of the bloc politics that currently split the world; it should exercise caution to avoid making any strict commitments that it will be unable to meet.

Pakistan does not have friendly relations with either its eastern or western borders at the regional level. Pakistan and India faced off in a low-level conflict during the Post Pahalgam crisis, which rippled through India’s reputation abroad and is currently regarded as the new normal in Indian policy circles. In October, cross-border militancy caused tensions between Pakistan and Afghanistan, its neighbor to the east, to deteriorate. The realignment of Indo-Afghan relations and the reopening of Pakistan’s embassy in Kabul opened the door for more widespread worries among Islamabad policy circles. The Indo-Pak and Af-Pak policies have not advanced. To prevent any two-frontal crises at its borders, Islamabad would have to normalize its relations with both countries.

To achieve its goals to emphasize economic diplomacy, maintain balance between the US and China, moderate in regional conflicts, and anchor its plan for internal stabilization, Pakistan needs a hedging policy. Pakistan must avoid making strict commitments to any large or middle countries in any alliance; development should be the guiding theme while security would still be crucial. Pakistan’s strength would come from more than just its location; it would also come from its credible leadership, internal strength, and external resilience; without these, its policies would be limited. Pakistan would make its strategic decision while staying non-aligned, avoiding joining any bloc, and adapting to the shifting landscape of global politics.

 

[1] Lodhi, Maleeha. 2025. “Foreign Policy Dilemmas.” DAWN.COM. January 6, 2025. https://www.dawn.com/news/1883399

[2] Iqbal, Anwar. 2025. “Analysis: After Years of Drift, 2025 Brings Thaw in Pak-US Ties.” Dawn. December 28, 2025. https://www.dawn.com/news/1963690

[3] Tarique Siyal. 2025. “Pakistan’s Foreign Policy: Balancing Global Alliances amid Shifting Geopolitics.” Thenews.com.pk. The News International. August 14, 2025. https://www.thenews.com.pk/latest/1335768-pakistans-foreign-policy-balancing-global-alliances-amid-shifting-geopolitics

[4] “Afghanistan-Pakistan Relations: Changing Dynamics in the Post-Pahalgam Scenario – Mantraya Institute for Strategic Studies.” 2025. Mantraya Institute for Strategic Studies – Strategy, Innovation & Alternatives. July 15, 2025. https://miss.org.in/afghanistan-pakistan-relations-changing-dynamics-in-the-post-pahalgam-scenario/

[5] “Welcome to Zscaler Directory Authentication.” 2025. Spinetimes.pk. 2025. https://spinetimes.pk/the-changing-dynamics-of-pakistans-foreign-policy/

 

‌

 

Basit Ali

Table of Contents

Basit Ali

Basit Ali is a research associate at the Maritime Centre of Excellence, Pakistan Navy War College, Lahore.

Share this post :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News

Subscribe our newsletter

Sign up our newsletter to get update information, news and free insight.