Pakistan is advancing a significant modernization of its naval capabilities through the acquisition of eight Hangor-class submarines, developed in collaboration with China, as it seeks to strengthen maritime deterrence and address the conventional naval imbalance with India. Equipped with Air Independent Propulsion (AIP) technology, advanced sensors, and stealth capabilities, the submarines are expected to enhance the Pakistan Navy’s underwater endurance, operational flexibility, and sea-denial capabilities in the Arabian Sea. The program also raises broader strategic questions about regional naval competition, the evolving balance of power in the Indian Ocean, and the role of conventional submarines in supporting asymmetric maritime warfare.
In an exclusive interview with Global Defense Insight (GDI), Abdur Rehman, a strategic affairs scholar, defense analyst, and Senior Lecturer in International Relations at the University of Central Punjab (UCP), examines the strategic significance of Pakistan’s Hangor-class submarine program and its implications for regional maritime security. A former instructor at the Pakistan Navy War College, Rehman shares his perspectives with Mansoor Zaman on asymmetric naval deterrence, the sustainability of Pakistan’s sea-denial strategy, the potential implications for second-strike capabilities, and the growing influence of China–India strategic competition in the Indian Ocean. He also discusses how Pakistan can integrate submarines with drones, maritime surveillance systems, and coastal defense capabilities to strengthen its naval posture against a conventionally superior adversary.
Pakistan has a much smaller navy than India. Can submarines realistically compensate for this conventional naval imbalance, or is Pakistan simply delaying the problem?
Ans: Pakistan does not have the capacity to match Indian ship for ship naval size, but it does effectively utilize its submarines for asymmetric sea-denial for naval threats. Pakistan plans to induct eight Hangor-class submarines in its naval fleet. It possess both stealth and state of the art Air Independent Propulsion System (AIP) that acts as a force multiplier against major threats. Their stealth capability creates a complex ‘problem of identifying the target’ for Indian navy. Thus, forcing the adversary to spend more funds and time deploying anti-submarine weapons while making their other high value targets like aircraft carriers vulnerable. Though, submarines are not enough to eradicate India’s broader maritime advantages, but it can be operated to integrate into the wider coastal defense network. Therefore, these stealth submarines transform India’s maritime superiority far more costly by raising the cost of ensuring credible deterrence in maritime affairs.
The Hangor-class gives Pakistan greater underwater endurance and capability. How it strengthens Pakistan’s sea-denial strategy, or can it trigger a costly naval arms race with India?
Ans: Pakistan will induct eight Hangor-class submarines in its fleet. Four of them will be built in China, while rest of them will be built in Pakistan. These machines would significantly advance Islamabad’s sea-denial strategy in its maritime domain as they are equipped with advanced sensors, state of the art Air Independent Propulsion System (AIP) and stealth capability. This allows the submarine to remain undetected underwater, with increased endurance, and boosted survivability. Pakistan can use these submarines to deter high value threats posed by surface ships and create uncertainty for the adversary by increasing the operational cost for Indian maritime forces in North of Arabian Sea. However, India is also strengthening its Anti-submarine Warfare (ASW) capabilities by developing its own AIP submarine system. The Hangor-class submarines do not dominate India’s naval dominance, but it effectively raises the risks and cost for maintaining a superior navy by increasing the cost of balance of power.
How significant is the Hangor-class for Pakistan’s second-strike capability and nuclear deterrence, particularly in context of India expanding its own nuclear submarine fleet?
Ans: The Hangor-class submarines with AIP systems strategically enhance Pakistan’s naval survivability and second-strike deterrence. It aims to confuse adversary’s targeting capability through stealth and extended endurance underwater. It is designed to support Pakistan’s sea based nuclear capability through nuclear capable Babur-3 cruise missiles. Despite its capabilities, Hangor-class submarines remain a conventional submarine with unconfirmed operational nuclear integration. However, India is expanding its nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarine (SSBN) fleet as it has recently inducted nuclear-powered INS Aridhaman in its fleet. Pakistan utilizes cost effective platforms for asymmetric deterrence against India to inject strategic uncertainty into India’s regional calculations. Therefore, these submarines strengthen Pakistan’s retaliatory credibility and provide reliable operational command.
Is investing heavily in submarines is most efficient use of Pakistan’s limited defense resources, or should it prioritize drones, missiles, mines and coastal defense?
Ans: Pakistan’s Hangor-class submarines are equipped with AIP and stealth technology to complicate the strategic calculations of India without requiring a massive expenditure of nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines (SSBNs). However, these submarines are expensive to acquire, operate, and maintain. Due to high financial costs, Pakistan cannot rely on such expensive machines for security. Instead, Hangor-class submarines serve as a vital maritime defense capability within a broader and layered maritime defense architecture. By integrating low-cost assets like drones, sea mines, and other maritime warfare assets with Hangor-class submarines, it can become highly effective against conventionally superior enemies.
China supplying Pakistan’s Hangor-class submarines, could Pakistan’s growing underwater capability become part of a wider China–India strategic competition in the Indian Ocean?
Ans: Pakistan’s acquisition of eight Hangor-class submarines would significantly modernize its naval fleet. Its main objective aims to maintain credible sea-denial capability against a larger and conventionally stronger enemy like India. Pakistan’s security requirements and deterrence in the Arabian Sea was the primary motive behind this acquisition rather than acting as China’s proxy. Though the program carries deep regional implications. A more capable Pakistani naval fleet will force India to divert anti-submarine and surveillance resources towards its western maritime region, disrupting its focus entirely from China’s presence in Eastern Indian Ocean region. Ultimately, it creates security-interdependence effect that risks initiating regional naval arms race and deepening Indian cooperation with its alliance partners like with USA in Quad.
India operates nuclear-powered submarines, while Pakistan’s most advanced Hangor-class submarines are diesel-electric. Does this technological gap create a strategic imbalance in submarine warfare and how Pakistan can overcome this?
Ans: India’s nuclear-powered submarine possess technological edge over Pakistan’s conventional naval fleet in terms of second-strike nuclear capability, sustained speed and operational capacity for longer period. Yet, this asymmetry does not create unbearable strategic imbalance for Pakistan. Pakistan’s Hangor-class Diesel-electric submarines are not nuclear powered, but it is equipped with Air Independent Propulsion System (AIP) that produce exceptionally low acoustic stealth in constrained environments like Arabian Sea. Pakistan maintains asymmetric sea-denial strategy against India by not involving in unsustainable and costly nuclear fleet to match the Indian fleet. By integrating the AIP system in submarines, while also expanding Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance (ISR) network and anti-ship missiles. Pakistan aims to preserve maritime deterrence by making naval power projection too expensive for the adversary.



