The Iran-US crisis is often misunderstood as a dispute over uranium enrichment and Iran’s nuclear non-proliferation commitments. While the nuclear issue remains central to US-Iran talks, a wider power struggle in the Middle East can explain the intensity and timing of present crisis. The shifting balance of power, diminishing old rivalries, emergence of new power blocs and their implications for regional and economic stability reflect a deeper structural transformation in the region.
The evolving regional landscape is a key driver for Israel’s escalation against Iran. After the Abraham Accords, Israel consolidated its strategic position and improved relations with Gulf states. However, following Gaza genocide, the Middle Eastern states are rethinking their strategic choices. Saudi Arabia, which was initially willing to join the Accords has recalibrated its foreign policy. After fall of Bashar al-Assad’s regime in Syria, other regional players like Türkiye are also reassessing their geo-political strategy. Israel has considerably damaged Hamas and Hezbollah by targeting their leadership after 7 Oct 23. As a result, Iran’s strategic maneuverability has reduced significantly in the region. However, the 12-day war between Israel and Iran has exposed both Israel’s vulnerabilities and Iran’s resilience. Iran’s ballistic missiles effectively breached the Israeli air defense system and targeted US bases in the region. The escalation presented Iran as a long-term strategic threat to Israel for its hegemonic designs in the region. Israel desires a politically, economically, and militarily weak Iran that will shift the balance of power in Israel’s favour. Therefore, Israel percives it’s the right time to change Islamic regime in Iran by exercising maximum pressure through Washington.
On the other hand, the US is pursuing a two-pronged strategy to get a favourable deal from Iran. Washington is engaged in indirect negotiations with Tehran and simultaneously strengthening its military presence through warships and fighter jets in Gulf. During the first presidency of Donald Trump, the US withdrawal from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action shifted its policy from engagement to “maximum pressure”. The US further maximized pressure on Iran through economic sanctions, diplomatic isolation and supported protests against Islamic regime. On negotiation table US is focused on a comprehensive agreement with Iran including nuclear programme, capping of ballistic missiles programme and actions against various proxies including Hamas, Houthis and Hezbullah.
Iran’s position is shaped by both internal and external pressures. At home, Tehran faces a financial crisis resulting from economic sanctions and prolonged diplomatic isolation, which have triggered mass protests against the government. After 12-days war with Israel in June 2025, Iran is weaker than before and willing to negotiate with Washington. A success at the negotiation table will end Iranian isolation as well as improve its economic condition. However, Iran appears to pursue a calibrated approach. As per the Iranian Foreign Minister, Iran is willing to discuss curbs on its nuclear programme, in exchange for sanctions relief, however, its missile stockpile is “non-negotiable”. The setback to Iran’s proxies and increasing domestic pressure have reduced Tehran’s leverage. However, despite its willingness to negotiate on nuclear programme, Iran is cognizant of the risks associated with lack of credible security guarantees from Washington and it is not viable for Tehran to renounce its ballistic missile capabilities.
The Iran-US crisis had its roots in shifting regional balance of power with global implications. Iran is the second largest Middle Eastern state, rich in oil and gas reserves, and strategically located next to Strait of Hormuz. The Strait of Hormuz is a key waterway that connects the Persian Gulf with the Gulf of Oman and the Arabian Sea. The US Energy Information Administration (EIA) describes it as the “world’s most important oil transit chokepoint”. Thus, spillover of Iran-US crisis into maritime domain may have ripple effects on global supply chains and energy prices. Any disruption at the Strait of Hormuz may result in complex security and legal challenges with far-reaching implications, exposing structural vulnerabilities within the global economic system.
Over the past years, the bilateral relations between Iran and other regional states like Saudi Arabia, Türkiye and UAE have improved considerably. The underlying objective is economic prosperity of Gulf states that can be achieved through sustained peace and stability in the region. The existing Iran-US impasse may result into a prolonged military conflict or a (less likely) quick regime change in Iran. The consequences of both scenarios will create political, economic, and security predicaments for the regional states manifesting through fluctuating oil prices, refugees’ crises and exposure of sectarian fault lines. An unstable Iran would provide strategic space to a stronger and unchallenged Israel. Though wary of Iran’s proxies and threats, an empowered Israel with hegemonic ambition poses a much bigger challenge to regional states. Thus, a successful deal on the negotiation table is the desired outcome for these states rather than a prolonged military conflict in their neighbourhood.
For Pakistan, the situation presents a complex strategic dilemma. Pakistan shares approximately 900 km border with Iran. Pakistan is not only connected to Iran geographically, but also socially, economically and religiously. An estimated 0.7 million Pakistani Zaireen visit Iran every year for ziaraat. The recent terrorist attacks in Baluchistan, the border province of Iran, and suicide attack in Islamabad underscore Pakistan’s security vulnerabilities. Any outcome of Iran-US conflict other than peaceful settlement will pose multifaceted challenge to already fragile security situation of Pakistan. The scenario becomes more complicated when viewed in the light of Pakistan’s long term strategic relations with the US. Thus, Pakistan’s options to stay out, remain neutral and watch from distance are limited.
The optimal strategy for Pakistan is sustained engagement with both Iran and US exercising pragmatic approach towards Washington while maintaining diplomatic ties with Tehran. Pakistan may leverage its improved relations with US to directly support de-escalation efforts. At the same time Islamabad’s multilateral engagements with states like Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and Türkiye may offer a pathway to reduce tensions. Pakistan’s role may not be decisive, but it can be constructive. In periods of regional transformation, middle powers can act as stabilizers if they prioritize mediation over alignment.
Any action, military or otherwise, which results in a fragile Iran, with economic constraints and political instability poses more challenges to the region. As a result, empowered non-state actors, disrupted trade routes and economic instability will bring only disorder and chaos in the region. The Middle East is undergoing strategic realignment. In such periods, coercion carries higher risks than anticipated. Stability will likely emerge not from regime collapse or military escalation, but from negotiated recalibration of power relations.
Table of Contents
ToggleMemoona Asmaar
The author is PhD Scholar in International Relation at Lahore College for Women University.




